"Well, I Muttered I Love You." by When In May: Song Review
- paradoccsblog
- 3 days ago
- 2 min read
3 words: Coy, Calm, Cohesive.

When In May delivers a shimmering lo-fi beat dipped in serenity and soft pop sounds, followed by faint vocals that communicate timidity. Wind chimes introduce the murky electric piano melody mixed with velvet production that spans an entire 1 minute and 9 seconds. This committed build up creates a sense of casualty that compliments the laid back soundscape. Flexibility with this tone pairs well with the subject of the song. The structure of the track parallels that of a muttered confession, where the beginning is prolonged and shy, mustering the courage to speak. Crafting a track that actively performs consistently with a plot that reflects the title contributes to a cohesiveness that is difficult to achieve. At 2 minutes and 20 seconds, When In May’s track is thoughtfully produced and retains attention. Between the brave intro, bashful vocals, and rich plot, this song behaves exactly as it's titled: “Well, I Muttered I Love You.”
When In May establishes themselves as “your new best friends, your new favorite band,” and they might be right. This band is talented, versatile, and kind. They released their first single “Cheap Red Wine” in 2023, and another single “After The Breakup” in 2024. Their first EP “Lying About Silly Things” was released in 2024 with 5 tracks. “Well, I Muttered I Love You.” is the 4th track on their latest EP “Dynamics In The Morning” released in May of this year. We can’t wait to see what they do next! Keep up with When In May using their social links below, and stream their EP!
If you liked When In May - you might also like:
For more of When In May:
By Paradoccs Blog
This review is the property of Paradoccs. Do not distribute or monetize without our permission.